With AEW Double or Nothing 2026 going down tonight, now feels like the right time to look back at what this pay-per-view has meant to the company from the beginning. Double or Nothing is not just another AEW event. It is the show that launched the promotion, became its Memorial Day weekend tradition and, at its best, reminded fans why AEW felt like a real alternative in the first place.
Every year has not hit the same. Some editions changed the company’s direction. Some delivered elite match quality, emotional storytelling and major title shifts. Others were bloated, uneven or carried by one or two moments while the rest of the card struggled to justify its length. So before AEW adds another chapter tonight, it is worth ranking every Double or Nothing from the first show through last year’s event.
This is not just about star ratings. It is about match quality, build, feuds, title matches, fan investment, expectations, storyline payoff, historical importance, overall reception and whether the event actually moved AEW forward.
7. AEW Double or Nothing 2023
This is the weakest Double or Nothing, and that does not mean the show had nothing good. MJF vs. Darby Allin vs. Jack Perry vs. Sammy Guevara was a strong world title match and probably the best possible version of the “Four Pillars” concept. The Elite vs. Blackpool Combat Club in Anarchy in the Arena had violence, heat and major storyline implications. Kris Statlander returning to end Jade Cargill’s undefeated streak was a major moment. Orange Cassidy continuing his International Championship run added real quality to the card.
The problem is that the show felt uneven, overstuffed and creatively messy. The build to the Four Pillars match had moments, but it also exposed the gap between MJF and the other three as top-of-the-card promo characters. The Adam Cole and Chris Jericho program never reached the emotional level AEW seemed to think it had. Jamie Hayter losing the women’s title while clearly not right physically made the division feel more unlucky than hot. The card had good pieces, but the full show never fully came together.
This was AEW in one of its more frustrating phases: enough talent to make almost anything watchable, but not enough clean storytelling to make the whole night feel essential. Double or Nothing 2023 had moments fans remember, but as a complete PPV, it sits at the bottom.
6. AEW Double or Nothing 2020
The 2020 show deserves credit because AEW made something entertaining during one of the strangest periods in wrestling history. No real crowd, no normal pay-per-view atmosphere and no traditional big-event energy — yet AEW still found a way to create moments people remembered.
The first Stadium Stampede was the obvious highlight. It was creative, ridiculous, funny, violent and perfectly built for the empty-arena pandemic era. Jon Moxley vs. Brodie Lee gave the AEW World Championship a hard-hitting defense. Hikaru Shida beating Nyla Rose was a strong title change. Cody beating Lance Archer to become the first TNT Champion gave that belt instant importance.
But this is still a pandemic show, and that matters. It had good wrestling and a legendary cinematic main event, but the lack of a true crowd naturally limited how big the night could feel. Some of the undercard was fine without being special, and the Cody/Archer finish with Mike Tyson involvement felt more like celebrity spectacle than great wrestling payoff.
Double or Nothing 2020 was impressive for what it was. It just was not stronger than the live-crowd editions that had better atmosphere, cleaner builds and bigger company-shifting consequences.
5. AEW Double or Nothing 2022
This is the most complicated Double or Nothing to rank because the highs were major, but the show was too long and the aftermath aged horribly.
CM Punk beating Hangman Page for the AEW World Championship was one of the biggest title changes in company history. At the time, it felt like AEW going all-in on its biggest mainstream star. Hangman vs. Punk had real tension because the story blurred the line between hero, challenger and company politics before fans even fully understood how messy things were about to become.
Wardlow destroying MJF should have been the perfect payoff to one of AEW’s best long-term stories. Anarchy in the Arena was pure madness in the best way. The first Owen Hart Cup finals gave the event historical value. On paper, there was a lot here that mattered.
But the show was bloated. Thirteen matches is too many, especially when a pay-per-view starts to feel like it is testing the audience’s patience instead of rewarding it. The MJF situation hanging over the weekend created noise that almost swallowed Wardlow’s moment. Punk winning the world title should have launched AEW into a bigger era, but instead it became the beginning of injuries, interim titles, backstage drama and one of the messiest chapters in company history.
Double or Nothing 2022 had important moments, but importance is not the same thing as greatness. It was a big show that often felt like it was fighting against itself.
4. AEW Double or Nothing 2024
The five-year anniversary show had the right idea: celebrate AEW’s past, push parts of its future and give fans the kind of chaos only AEW would even attempt. It mostly worked.
Mercedes Moné making her AEW in-ring debut and beating Willow Nightingale for the TBS Championship felt like a true business move. Will Ospreay winning the International Championship continued AEW strapping a rocket to one of the best wrestlers in the world. Swerve Strickland retaining the AEW World Championship against Christian Cage gave Swerve’s reign a solid PPV defense, even if the feud never felt like the hottest possible world title program.
Adam Copeland vs. Malakai Black had strong presentation, Gangrel’s involvement gave the match a major surprise, and MJF’s return gave the show the big closing-level moment it needed. Anarchy in the Arena was wild, excessive and ridiculous in the exact way AEW fans either love or roll their eyes at. This version leaned closer to working because Bryan Danielson, Darby Allin, FTR, The Elite, Kazuchika Okada and Jack Perry gave it star power and violence.
The issue is that the show also felt like AEW trying to do everything at once. Three “main events” can make a card feel stacked, but it can also make the night feel like it does not know what the real centerpiece is. Still, 2024 was a strong anniversary show and a reminder that AEW’s ceiling remained high when the company gives its biggest matches the presentation they deserve.
3. AEW Double or Nothing 2021
Double or Nothing 2021 had something no empty-arena show could manufacture: the sound of AEW fans fully coming back to life. That alone gives the event a special place in company history. It was the final major Daily’s Place pandemic-era PPV, but it also felt like the first real step back toward normal.
Kenny Omega vs. Orange Cassidy vs. PAC was excellent and proved Orange Cassidy could belong in a world title match without losing what made him different. The Young Bucks vs. Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston was one of the best matches of the night and captured how good AEW’s tag division could be when it had personality, violence and real stakes. Britt Baker beating Hikaru Shida felt like a necessary changing of the guard. Sting and Darby Allin had the right kind of crowd-pleasing presentation.
The Stadium Stampede main event depends on taste. Some loved it. Some thought it felt more like a movie than a wrestling main event. Both can be true. Cody Rhodes vs. Anthony Ogogo also dragged the card down and remains one of the more awkward creative choices of that era.
Still, the positives mattered more. Double or Nothing 2021 felt like AEW surviving the pandemic era and stepping into one of the hottest runs the company has ever had.
2. AEW Double or Nothing 2025
The 2025 show is the strongest pure wrestling card in Double or Nothing history. Hangman Page vs. Will Ospreay was the kind of main event that made the entire show feel bigger by the time it ended. It had elite match quality, major future consequences and the emotional weight of Hangman trying to claw his way back toward the top of AEW. Ospreay delivered like Ospreay always does, but Hangman winning gave the night a real narrative spine.
Mercedes Moné vs. Jamie Hayter opened the main card with a major-fight feel. Anarchy in the Arena delivered the violent spectacle AEW fans expect from that match, and the mix of the Death Riders, The Elite, Kenny Omega and Swerve Strickland gave the show a chaotic main-event-level aura even before the actual main event. Toni Storm vs. Mina Shirakawa gave the women’s world title scene more texture, and the card had enough depth to feel like a major PPV, not just a one-match show.
The issue, once again, was length. AEW still has a problem knowing when enough is enough. Some matches could have been tighter. Some sections needed breathing room. But when the best parts of a show are that good, the flaws do not sink it.
Double or Nothing 2025 felt like AEW using its roster properly, centering the Owen Hart Cup, rebuilding Hangman and giving fans a main event worthy of the hype. It was not the most historically important Double or Nothing, but bell-to-bell, it was one of the best.
1. AEW Double or Nothing 2019
The original still stands at the top because no other Double or Nothing had this level of pressure, purpose and payoff. AEW had to prove it was not just a T-shirt company, not just a press conference promotion and not just a wrestling Twitter dream. It had to prove it could produce a major pay-per-view that felt like the beginning of something real.
It did.
Cody vs. Dustin Rhodes was the emotional backbone of the entire show and still might be the most important match in AEW history. It was bloody, dramatic, personal and told with a level of clarity AEW has not always maintained since. The Young Bucks vs. The Lucha Brothers gave the show its high-end tag team identity. Chris Jericho defeating Kenny Omega gave AEW a credible first world title direction. Bret Hart unveiling the AEW World Championship added history. Jon Moxley showing up at the end made the company feel dangerous, fresh and immediately relevant.
Was the whole show perfect? No. Some of it aged like a first episode, because that is exactly what it was. But the atmosphere, audience, timing and significance make it impossible to rank anywhere else.
Double or Nothing 2019 did not just move AEW forward. It made AEW possible.
Final Ranking
- AEW Double or Nothing 2019
- AEW Double or Nothing 2025
- AEW Double or Nothing 2021
- AEW Double or Nothing 2024
- AEW Double or Nothing 2022
- AEW Double or Nothing 2020
- AEW Double or Nothing 2023
Final Thoughts
Double or Nothing 2026 now walks into tonight with a lot to live up to. The standard is not just having great matches. AEW can almost always do that. The real test is whether tonight’s show feels important when it is over. Does it move stories forward? Does it make the world title picture clearer? Does it reward the audience for following the road to the show? Does it create moments that matter beyond one weekend?
That is what separates the best Double or Nothing shows from the forgettable ones. 2019 was the revolution. 2020 was survival. 2021 was the return of the crowd. 2022 was ambition turning into chaos. 2023 was the warning sign of uneven creative. 2024 was the anniversary reset. 2025 was AEW reminding everyone that when the wrestling and stakes line up, it can still deliver one of the best major shows in the business.
Tonight, AEW gets another chance to add to that history. And with this event, the bar should always be high.
Make sure to subscribe to our Late Night Crew Wrestling YouTube Channel. Follow @yorkjavon, @kspowerwheels & @LateNightCrewYT on X.
I’m the quiet one until the bell rings then I’ve got takes. I live for WWE NXT and TNA, I want every promotion to succeed, and I will absolutely roast the bad decisions on sight (because someone has to). Anime taught me to respect long-term storytelling; wrestling taught me that sometimes the plan is “we panicked” and called it “unpredictable.” The Miz got me into all of this, so yeah I appreciate confidence, commitment, and the art of talking like you’re already the main event. Now I bring that same energy to the page as the main writer for Late Night Crew Wrestling because if you’re not here to be must-see and tell the truth, why are you here?!