A rivalry that began with GUNTHER refusing to accept another controversial championship failure now appears destined for one of SummerSlam’s most intriguing special attractions. Mike Johnson of PWInsider Elite reports that GUNTHER versus SmackDown General Manager Nick Aldis is “100% set” for WWE SummerSlam in Minneapolis, adding that the recent physical confrontations are not merely teasing a match for somewhere further down the line. Should WWE follow through with its current plans, the bout would mark Aldis’ first match inside a WWE ring.
WWE has not officially announced the match, but the report gives a clear destination to a storyline the company has deliberately escalated over the past several weeks. SummerSlam will take place across two nights on August 1 and August 2 at U.S. Bank Stadium in Minneapolis.
GUNTHER’s championship failures created the conflict
The foundation was laid during GUNTHER’s pursuit of Cody Rhodes and the Undisputed WWE Championship.
After defeating Royce Keys to become the No. 1 Contender, GUNTHER challenged Cody at Clash in Italy. Cody retained, but the referee failed to notice GUNTHER’s foot underneath the bottom rope during the deciding pinfall. WWE then granted GUNTHER a rematch and allowed him to select a special stipulation. He chose Sami Zayn as the guest referee, believing Sami’s problems with Cody would work in his favor.
Instead, Sami lost control of the match, attacked a replacement official and used a fast count that cost GUNTHER another opportunity to become champion.
Nick Aldis responded by adding Sami to the championship match at Night of Champions. Sami ultimately defeated Cody and GUNTHER in a Triple Threat Match, pinning Cody to capture the first world championship of his WWE career. GUNTHER once again left without being defeated himself, but he also left without the championship he believed should have belonged to him.
That was where the story stopped being strictly about the title.
Following Night of Champions, an enraged GUNTHER confronted Aldis and accused the SmackDown General Manager of deliberately sabotaging him. He claimed Aldis was jealous of his success, dismissed him as a failed wrestler and turned the argument physical. WWE later announced that GUNTHER had been sent home while Aldis was placed on administrative leave as the company investigated the confrontation.
GUNTHER’s accusation worked because it contained just enough truth to make his anger understandable. He had lost two championship matches through controversial officiating, and Aldis had placed Sami—the man who fast-counted him—into the Night of Champions Triple Threat. From GUNTHER’s perspective, Aldis repeatedly added obstacles instead of recognizing him as the rightful challenger.
The flaw in GUNTHER’s argument is that Aldis never denied him opportunities. Aldis booked the match that made him No. 1 Contender, granted him his first championship match, approved another opportunity following the disputed finish and allowed GUNTHER to choose the stipulation. GUNTHER personally selected Sami as the referee. His inability to control his temper and the chaos surrounding him repeatedly became his downfall.
Rather than accept any responsibility, GUNTHER made Aldis the embodiment of every system he believed had failed him.
GUNTHER unintentionally created Punk versus Cody
The storyline intensified when Cody earned another championship match following Sami’s Night of Champions victory. Before Cody could receive that opportunity on the July 6 episode of Raw, GUNTHER ruthlessly attacked him and left him unable to compete.
CM Punk replaced Cody, defeated Sami and became the new Undisputed WWE Champion. GUNTHER’s attempt to destroy Cody’s opportunity inadvertently opened the door for Punk’s championship victory and created an entirely new title picture.
Aldis returned from administrative leave four days later and immediately sanctioned Punk versus Cody for SummerSlam. Cody had earned a championship match before GUNTHER took him out, while Punk had captured the title by replacing him. From a management perspective, Punk versus Cody was the logical solution.
To GUNTHER, it was another example of Aldis rewarding everyone except him.
GUNTHER confronted Aldis during the July 10 SmackDown and gave him until the end of the night to correct what he considered a major injustice. Aldis refused to remove Punk versus Cody from SummerSlam. Instead, he booked Punk and Cody against GUNTHER and Sami at Saturday Night’s Main Event.
GUNTHER wanted a championship match. Aldis gave him a non-title tag-team match alongside the man connected to his previous failures.
That was not enough.
GUNTHER attacked Aldis, drilled him with strikes and repeatedly trapped him in the Sleeper Hold as officials attempted to intervene. Cody eventually returned to rescue Aldis as SmackDown went off the air.
The attack removed any remaining distance between the General Manager and the wrestler beneath the suit.
Why Nick Aldis is more than another authority figure
Calling Aldis a failed wrestler was not a random insult. It was GUNTHER deliberately targeting the identity Aldis has kept largely hidden during his WWE run.
Before becoming SmackDown General Manager in October 2023, Aldis built his career as a traditional heavyweight world champion. He held the NWA Worlds Heavyweight Championship twice, including a 1,044-day reign, and previously captured the TNA World Heavyweight Championship. Although he has not wrestled since joining WWE, Aldis has made it clear that he would be ready if the company ever needed him to compete.
That history makes this more compelling than the usual wrestler-against-management program. Aldis is not an executive attempting to hide behind security guards and corporate authority. He is a former world champion who has spent nearly three years presenting himself as a composed and impartial General Manager.
GUNTHER has spent weeks attacking that composure.
He has questioned Aldis’ career, blamed him for championship failures and physically humiliated him in his own workplace. After Cody had to save Aldis from the Sleeper Hold, administrative punishment alone would feel like an incomplete response. GUNTHER has forced Aldis into a situation where standing across the ring from him may be the only way to restore the authority and respect that have been stripped away.
The right SummerSlam direction for both men
GUNTHER versus Aldis also solves a difficult creative problem.
GUNTHER was heavily involved in the Undisputed WWE Championship picture but no longer fits naturally into Punk versus Cody. Adding him would complicate a SummerSlam title match that already has enough history and tension on its own. Moving GUNTHER into an ordinary midcard rivalry, however, would feel like a major step backward after months of pursuing WWE’s biggest championship.
Aldis’ first WWE match gives GUNTHER a major singles attraction without forcing him into the title match. It allows Punk versus Cody to remain intact while giving GUNTHER a deeply personal story against an established former world champion.
The match should also benefit Aldis without requiring WWE to pretend he has been competing every week. GUNTHER should enter as the sharper and more dangerous active wrestler. Aldis’ role should be to absorb the punishment, survive longer than expected and remind everyone that his championship reputation was earned long before he began running SmackDown.
Aldis does not need to defeat GUNTHER to justify the match. Standing across from The Ring General after being repeatedly told that he was never good enough could restore the credibility GUNTHER attempted to take away from him. GUNTHER versus Nick Aldis would give SummerSlam a deeply personal special attraction while allowing Punk versus Cody to remain focused on the Undisputed WWE Championship.
What began as GUNTHER blaming management for his own championship failures has developed into something much more personal: one of WWE’s most dominant wrestlers attempting to prove that the man controlling SmackDown was never qualified to stand above him—and Aldis preparing to prove that he can still stand directly across from him.
Make sure to subscribe to our Late Night Crew Wrestling YouTube Channel. Follow @yorkjavon, @kspowerwheels & @LateNightCrewYT on X.
I’m the quiet one until the bell rings then I’ve got takes. I live for WWE NXT and TNA, I want every promotion to succeed, and I will absolutely roast the bad decisions on sight (because someone has to). Anime taught me to respect long-term storytelling; wrestling taught me that sometimes the plan is “we panicked” and called it “unpredictable.” The Miz got me into all of this, so yeah I appreciate confidence, commitment, and the art of talking like you’re already the main event. Now I bring that same energy to the page as the main writer for Late Night Crew Wrestling because if you’re not here to be must-see and tell the truth, why are you here?!