The report making the rounds on Wednesday appears to be rooted in a real Wrestling Observer Radio update, but the most important part of the story is not just that a planned WWE Backlash tag match was scrapped. It is why it was reportedly scrapped.
Multiple secondary outlets are now attributing the same core claim to Dave Meltzer: a Randy Orton & Pat McAfee vs. Cody Rhodes & Jelly Roll tag match was in the post-WrestleMania plans for Backlash, but McAfee ultimately “opted out,” with fan reaction to celebrity-heavy involvement in the Rhodes-Orton feud said to be a major factor. At the same time, there is still no official WWE confirmation of either the original plan or the reported change, so it should be treated as a well-circulated backstage report, not established fact from the company itself.
What is confirmed is the larger context that made this report believable the second it surfaced. WWE itself presented Pat McAfee as a major piece of the WrestleMania 42 Saturday main event story, first in the build and then in the match itself. On the official result, McAfee attacked Cody Rhodes before the bell, got wiped out by Rhodes and Jelly Roll, returned later dressed as an official, then got dropped by Randy Orton before Rhodes retained the Undisputed WWE Championship.
That angle was supposed to feel big, chaotic and crossover-friendly. Instead, it became one of the most criticized pieces of WWE’s WrestleMania season. Cageside Seats noted the negative reaction before WrestleMania, writing that fans and analysts largely agreed McAfee’s addition dragged the main event down, and followed that with post-show coverage highlighting the continued criticism around celebrity overkill at WrestleMania 42. Wrestling Inc. also surfaced Bully Ray’s blunt assessment that nobody wanted McAfee involved in this particular story, while 411Mania reported Meltzer’s account that WWE had already started backing off after the fan response turned sharply negative.
That is what makes this latest report land harder than a routine creative-change story. It does not read like WWE simply changing directions. It reads like WWE running head-first into a reaction it could not ignore.
McAfee’s own public comments only add to that reading. After WrestleMania, he said on his show that the business “doesn’t need to be saved after all” and described wrestling as being in the “rearview mirror,” signaling that he was following through on the stipulation-based exit attached to Orton’s loss. Meanwhile, Jelly Roll later joked in his vlog that neither he nor McAfee had any business being there, a line delivered in character but one that still echoed the exact criticism fans had been voicing for weeks.
If the report is accurate, that matters because it reframes the whole saga. This was not just a celebrity cameo that missed the mark. It was a warning shot about how far even WWE can push crossover spectacle before it starts damaging the core story. Rhodes vs. Orton should have sold itself as a headline world title feud built on history, betrayal and star power. Instead, too much of the conversation got swallowed by McAfee, Jelly Roll, sponsorship noise and the feeling that the company was dressing up a major main event with accessories it did not need.
That is the real news here. Not that a Backlash tag match may have been shelved, but that WWE seems to have finally recognized the audience was rejecting the packaging around one of its biggest stories. If McAfee truly stepped aside because he and Jelly Roll did not want to add to the negativity, that is honestly the most self-aware decision anyone involved in this angle could have made.
In the end, the report fits the evidence. WWE pushed McAfee hard in the Rhodes-Orton program. The backlash was loud. WrestleMania paid that story off by effectively removing him. McAfee then publicly framed his wrestling run as finished. Now comes word that the celebrity tag match follow-up is dead. None of that proves every rumor detail is gospel, but taken together, it paints a very clear picture: WWE tried to make a major title feud bigger with celebrity involvement, and instead exposed the exact point where fans decided enough was enough.
Make sure to subscribe to our Late Night Crew Wrestling YouTube Channel. Follow @yorkjavon, @kspowerwheels & @LateNightCrewYT on X.
I’m the quiet one until the bell rings then I’ve got takes. I live for WWE NXT and TNA, I want every promotion to succeed, and I will absolutely roast the bad decisions on sight (because someone has to). Anime taught me to respect long-term storytelling; wrestling taught me that sometimes the plan is “we panicked” and called it “unpredictable.” The Miz got me into all of this, so yeah I appreciate confidence, commitment, and the art of talking like you’re already the main event. Now I bring that same energy to the page as the main writer for Late Night Crew Wrestling because if you’re not here to be must-see and tell the truth, why are you here?!