WWE Survivor Series: WarGames 2025 delivered major storyline developments, high-level star power, and the final Premium Live Event appearance of John Cena — but the overall fan and critic reaction to the show has landed squarely in “mixed territory.” While moments such as Liv Morgan’s shocking return, AJ Lee’s submission victory in her first-ever WarGames match, and Bron Breakker pinning CM Punk generated enormous conversation, both WarGames matches drew polarized responses. Add in the debate surrounding whether WarGames should remain the “modern tradition” of Survivor Series, and you have one of WWE’s most hotly debated PLEs of the year.

Below is a complete breakdown of how fans and analysts graded the event, what worked, what didn’t, and where WWE stands heading into Cena’s final match at Saturday Night’s Main Event.

Overall Fan and Critic Reception: A Divided Audience but Strong Talking Points

Professional reviews and fan discussions across Twitter, Reddit, Facebook Groups, and wrestling news outlets show a clear trend: Survivor Series 2025 wasn’t a disaster and wasn’t a masterpiece — it was a polarizing middle ground with big highs and frustrating lows.

Critic Response

• ProWrestling.net praised the event for delivering “three of the four matches at a high level,” especially the emotion of Cena vs. Dominik Mysterio and the spectacle of the men’s WarGames match.
• CBS Sports called the show “solid but uneven,” pointing out that the angles were intriguing but sometimes overshadowed the matches themselves.
• Several outlets emphasized the historic stadium atmosphere, the returns, and the star power but noted the event “did not reshape WWE” the way a Survivor Series with WarGames should.

Fan Response

Fan reaction was sharply split:

• Some fans called it “an enjoyable PLE from start to finish” and praised the chaos, the production, and the star appearances.
• Others blasted the pacing of the WarGames matches, the heavy use of interference, and the lack of emotional payoff for Cena’s last PLE outing.
• A vocal portion of the audience stated that the traditional 5-on-5 Survivor Series elimination matches should return, arguing that WarGames no longer feels unique.

The consensus: Survivor Series was entertaining but flawed.

Women’s WarGames Match: Strong Performances but Lacking Stakes

AJ Lee submitting Becky Lynch with the Black Widow in her WarGames debut generated widespread praise, as did Lash Legend’s first-ever appearance inside the double cage alongside her partner Nia Jax. Social media celebrated Lash’s standout moments, with many fans calling it a “breakout performance” and sharing highlight clips.

But despite the individual performances, critics and fans said the match lacked the escalation and drama WarGames demands. Several outlets noted it felt “too safe,” relying on predictable pacing instead of delivering the kind of violent creativity that defined earlier main roster WarGames matches.

Verdict: Good match, big moments, but missing the special aura expected from a WarGames bout.

John Cena vs. Dominik Mysterio: Emotional, Well-Received, and a Proper Ending

While fans were divided about Cena losing his final PLE match, most analysts agree the booking made narrative sense. Dominik retaining the Intercontinental Championship with help from returning Liv Morgan protected his heel momentum, reignited the Dom/Liv act, and allowed Cena to step cleanly into his final storyline — his retirement match on December 13.

The finish was emotional, with Cena rising to his feet post-match, saluting the crowd, and receiving a thunderous “Thank You Cena” chant. It offered closure without overshadowing the new generation.

Verdict: Divisive emotionally, but critically praised as smart storytelling.

Men’s WarGames Match: Big Moments, Big Controversy

Bron Breakker pinning CM Punk was widely recognized as a major star-making moment — but fans and critics were frustrated by the execution. The masked attacker’s interference felt mistimed to many, and the finish overshadowed the in-ring story instead of enhancing it.

Still, no one denied that Breakker pinning Punk deepens the ongoing feud between Punk and The Vision and sets the stage for a massive storyline reveal heading into 2026.

Verdict: Spectacle-heavy, but the finish underdelivered for some fans despite its storyline importance.

Should WarGames Remain the Modern Survivor Series Tradition?

On commentary, Michael Cole referred to WarGames as “the modern tradition of Survivor Series,” echoing WWE’s branding strategy since 2022.

But after this year’s show, fans questioned whether the format has lost its magic.

Arguments from Fans Wanting Change

• WarGames matches feel formulaic and too long before “the match beyond” can begin.
• Too many multi-man cage spots create chaos without emotional stakes.
• Survivor Series’ classic identity — elimination matches — has been lost.

Arguments from Fans Who Want WarGames to Stay

• WarGames still offers unmatched visuals and spectacle.
• When booked well, it creates career-defining moments (Breakker pinning Punk).
• It remains one of the few PLE structures that feels “big four worthy.”

Fan suggestion trending on Twitter:

“One WarGames match per year — and bring back at least one traditional Survivor Series elimination match.”

Final Grade: B-

After evaluating critical reviews, fan reactions, social media sentiment, and match-by-match performance, the fairest overall grade for Survivor Series: WarGames 2025 is:

Overall Score: B-

• The highs: Liv Morgan’s return, AJ Lee’s submission win, Lash Legend’s debut, Bron Breakker’s pin on Punk, Cena’s final PLE moment.
• The lows: Over-booked finishes, inconsistent WarGames pacing, storyline overshadowing wrestling, and complaints about format fatigue.

It wasn’t a bad show — far from it. It was a good-but-flawed stadium event that created major story momentum but left fans debating whether Survivor Series needs to evolve again.

Make sure to subscribe to our Late Night Crew Wrestling YouTube Channel. Follow @yorkjavon, @kspowerwheels & @LateNightCrewYT on X.