Tonight’s WWE Friday Night SmackDown has a lot riding on it, and not just because WrestleMania 42 is around the corner. On paper, the blue brand should be in a strong position. The top matches are set, the stakes are clear, and the road to Las Vegas is supposed to be tightening into focus. Instead, last week’s Pat McAfee reveal as Randy Orton’s mystery caller has turned the biggest SmackDown story into one of the most criticized creative choices WWE has made on the road to WrestleMania. Cody Rhodes vs. Randy Orton never lacked heat, history, or emotional weight. It already had everything it needed. That is why tonight feels so important. This is not just another preview show. It is WWE’s chance to either sharpen the blue brand’s biggest feud again or keep dragging it sideways with a twist that a lot of fans, writers, and pundits think actively hurt the story.
Here is everything advertised for tonight’s show
- Cody Rhodes responds to the assault by Randy Orton and Pat McAfee
- Drew McIntyre promises to expose the real Jacob Fatu
- Sami Zayn looks for payback on Trick Williams
- Royce Keys makes his SmackDown debut
The center of the show is obviously Cody Rhodes dealing with the fallout from last week. WWE’s official preview is built around that question, and that tells you everything about what the company sees as tonight’s anchor. Last week, Orton aligned himself with McAfee and the reveal was positioned like a major payoff after weeks of mystery. WWE’s own official results page framed it as the defining development of the episode. The issue is that the reveal landed with far more criticism than excitement, because the mystery itself had been built as something bigger, something more personal, or at least something more organically tied to Orton’s story. Instead, the answer was McAfee, and that immediately pulled attention away from Cody and Orton and onto the booking itself.
That is the core problem WWE has to deal with tonight. Cody vs. Orton is strong enough on its own. It is a WrestleMania feud built on history, betrayal, legacy, and title stakes. It did not need an extra layer that felt more like a talking point than an actual dramatic necessity. That is why so much of the reaction last week turned negative. The criticism was not really about whether McAfee can talk or whether he has star power. It was about fit. The reveal felt like it belonged to a different story than the one WWE had been telling. Instead of deepening Orton’s turn or making Cody’s fight feel more urgent, it created a meta conversation about overbooking, corporate influence, and whether WWE got too cute with a feud that was already hot enough.
That is also why the backlash has lingered. Cageside’s recap openly treated the reveal as a questionable storyline choice so close to WrestleMania, while the New York Post was even harsher in calling it a dud and arguing that WWE created a mess it now has to clean up. Even among viewers who liked the shock value, there has been a consistent feeling that the Pat McAfee addition risks overshadowing the stronger story, which is Cody trying to survive a version of Randy Orton that has fully embraced the most dangerous parts of himself again. Cody’s own response last week helped the situation because it cut directly into that criticism and felt like the first time the feud found its edge again after the reveal. Tonight needs more of that. It needs Cody and Orton to feel like the point, not McAfee.
The timeline matters here. Orton won the right to challenge Cody at WrestleMania 42, then WWE lit the fuse on March 13 when Orton attacked Cody during their contract signing. The feud escalated over the following weeks, and by the time SmackDown hit St. Louis on April 3, WWE finally answered the weeks-long mystery by revealing McAfee as Orton’s guy. Now tonight is the first real follow-up show after the dust settled, which makes it less about shock and more about execution. If WWE keeps McAfee as a side dish and lets Cody and Orton drive the story, the feud can recover quickly. If the company keeps presenting McAfee as the engine of the angle, the criticism is only going to get louder.
Elsewhere on the show, Drew McIntyre and Jacob Fatu have a real chance to steal some of the spotlight. WWE is advertising Drew promising to expose the “real” Jacob Fatu, and that is a smart direction for this feud. Their WrestleMania match is already unsanctioned, so the violence is sold. What the story needs now is sharper character motivation. Drew has enough intensity to make that work, and Jacob already brings menace just by showing up. If tonight’s segment lands, this could quietly become one of the strongest late-build WrestleMania programs on the blue brand because it feels raw, mean, and much less cluttered than the Cody-Orton-McAfee situation.
Sami Zayn and Trick Williams are in a good spot too. Last week’s show did exactly what it needed to do with them. Sami retained the United States Championship over Carmelo Hayes, and Trick stayed central to the story by attacking after the match. The booking there was much cleaner than the top feud. Sami comes off like the battle-tested champion, Trick comes off like the star who believes he is already bigger than the belt, and the conflict is simple enough that WWE does not have to force anything. Tonight’s payback setup should just keep that momentum going. This is one of the easier WrestleMania matches on the blue brand to get right, and so far WWE largely has.
Royce Keys making his SmackDown debut is the smallest official item on the card, but it still gives the show something fresh. On a night where so much of the focus is going to be promo-heavy and angle-driven, even a smaller debut can help the pacing if WWE presents it with purpose. It may not be a headline segment, but it is still part of the broader push to make this episode feel like more than just fallout television.
The broader road to WrestleMania 42 for SmackDown is mostly clear now. Cody Rhodes vs. Randy Orton is the marquee blue-brand title story, but it is also the one under the most scrutiny because of the McAfee reveal. Drew McIntyre vs. Jacob Fatu feels like the hard-hitting grudge fight. Sami Zayn vs. Trick Williams has become one of the cleaner secondary title builds. The frustrating part is that SmackDown actually has enough strong material heading into WrestleMania. That is what makes the criticism of the Pat McAfee twist hit harder. Fans and media are not rejecting the entire blue brand. They are reacting to the feeling that WWE complicated the one feud that was already doing the heavy lifting on its own.
Current WrestleMania 42 card
- Cody Rhodes (c) vs. Randy Orton (with Pat McAfee) (Undisputed WWE Championship)
- Stephanie Vaquer (c) vs. Liv Morgan (WWE Women’s World Championship)
- Seth Rollins vs. Gunther
- AJ Lee (c) vs. Becky Lynch (WWE Women’s Intercontinental Championship)
- The Irresistible Forces (c) vs. Charlotte Flair & Alexa Bliss vs. Bayley & Lyra Valkyria vs. The Bella Twins (WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship Fatal 4-Way)
- Jacob Fatu vs. Drew McIntyre (Unsanctioned Match)
- Logan Paul, Austin Theory & IShowSpeed vs. The Usos & LA Knight
- CM Punk (c) vs. Roman Reigns (WWE World Heavyweight Championship)
- Jade Cargill (c) vs. Rhea Ripley (WWE Women’s Championship)
- “The Demon” Finn Bálor vs. Dominik Mysterio
- Sami Zayn (c) vs. Trick Williams (WWE United States Championship)
- Oba Femi vs. Brock Lesnar
- Penta (c) vs. Je’Von Evans vs. Dragon Lee vs. JD McDonagh vs. Rusev vs. Rey Mysterio (WWE Intercontinental Championship Ladder Match)
Final thoughts
Tonight’s SmackDown should be about restoring focus. The blue brand has enough good material going into WrestleMania 42 that this show really should not need gimmicks or extra noise. Cody and Orton have the history. Drew and Jacob have the violence. Sami and Trick have the momentum. The problem is that last week’s Pat McAfee reveal turned the biggest SmackDown feud into a debate about booking more than a fight between two top stars. That is why the criticism has been so loud, and honestly, fairly so. WWE has one show left to prove it understands that the real money is still in Cody Rhodes vs. Randy Orton, not in the controversy created by forcing McAfee deeper into the mix. If tonight corrects that, SmackDown can head to WrestleMania strong. If it does not, the biggest blue-brand story will keep feeling more overthought than over.
Make sure to subscribe to our Late Night Crew Wrestling YouTube Channel. Follow @yorkjavon, @kspowerwheels & @LateNightCrewYT on X.
I’m the quiet one until the bell rings then I’ve got takes. I live for WWE NXT and TNA, I want every promotion to succeed, and I will absolutely roast the bad decisions on sight (because someone has to). Anime taught me to respect long-term storytelling; wrestling taught me that sometimes the plan is “we panicked” and called it “unpredictable.” The Miz got me into all of this, so yeah I appreciate confidence, commitment, and the art of talking like you’re already the main event. Now I bring that same energy to the page as the main writer for Late Night Crew Wrestling because if you’re not here to be must-see and tell the truth, why are you here?!