From Young Lions to Tag Team Royalty: A-Town Down Under’s Journey to WrestleMania and Beyond
In professional wrestling, some alliances feel destined, forged through shared ambition, charisma, and chaos. Others, born of necessity or timing, catch fire in unexpected ways. WWE’s A-Town Down Under – the unlikely tandem of Austin Theory and Grayson Waller – was both. Two cocky, charismatic, and cunning young stars from opposite hemispheres collided in the heart of WWE’s tag team division, rocketed to stardom with Tag Team Championship gold at WrestleMania 40, and have since spiraled toward an increasingly volatile implosion.
But before the sparks flew, there were the spotlights they earned on their own.
Austin Theory: The Prodigy from A-Town
Austin Theory’s WWE journey began with hype, headlines, and high expectations. Signed to NXT in 2019 after turning heads on the independent scene as EVOLVE Champion, Theory entered WWE as a blue-chip athlete with a sculpted frame, cocky confidence, and undeniable in-ring potential. He was briefly introduced to the main roster during the pandemic era, aligning with Seth Rollins and then Andrade, but returned to NXT to further refine his character – and it worked.
In The Way, the unforgettable NXT faction led by Johnny Gargano, Theory found his comedic timing, a spark of charm, and a character that connected. The “dumb jock” sidekick persona allowed Theory to loosen up, and when he returned to the main roster for good, he was no longer green – he was golden.
Backed by Mr. McMahon himself in 2022, Theory would go on to win the Money in the Bank briefcase (and become the youngest holder in history), capture the United States Championship twice, and defeat John Cena in a career-defining match at WrestleMania 39. He wasn’t just a star in the making – he was already here.
Grayson Waller: The Arrogant Architect of Attention
Meanwhile, in Australia, a loudmouthed former schoolteacher named Matty Wahlberg transformed into Grayson Waller, WWE’s ultimate clout chaser.
Signed in 2021, Waller brought his love of social media, fast talking, and quicker striking to NXT, standing out almost instantly. While many NXT stars tried to emulate legends, Waller focused on building buzz. He threw hands with Johnny Gargano in his farewell match, crashed WWE Hall of Fame events, and introduced the world to The Grayson Waller Effect – WWE’s most toxic talk show.
He challenged Bron Breakker for the NXT Championship, made headlines for his heat with Shawn Michaels, and was called up to SmackDown in 2023 with a red-hot mic and even hotter ambitions.
Though he didn’t win gold in NXT, he didn’t need to. Waller was a star based on presence alone.
From Rivals to Partners: The Birth of A-Town Down Under
It started as a segment. One arrogant loudmouth hosting another on The Grayson Waller Effect. Waller welcomed Theory in mid-2023 following his loss of the United States Championship – but rather than clash, they clicked.
Two delusional egos. Two perfectly styled haircuts. Two influencers with something to prove. The chemistry was undeniable. Whether mocking their opponents, manipulating backstage politics, or swiping the spotlight, Theory and Waller operated with the same chip on their shoulder and the same refusal to be ignored.
The name A-Town Down Under said it all. Part swagger, part satire – all synergy.
WrestleMania Glory: Tag Team Gold at the Showcase of the Immortals
Their ascent as a duo culminated at WrestleMania 40 in Philadelphia, where they shockingly captured the SmackDown Tag Team Championships in a chaotic Fatal 4-Way ladder match. While many assumed their gimmick had a short shelf life, Theory and Waller proved they were more than just personalities – they could go.
Their post-WrestleMania reign saw wins over veteran teams like The New Day, The Brawling Brutes, and Legado del Fantasma. They used distractions, underhanded tactics, and timing to stay one step ahead. In promos, they oozed confidence. On social media, they were viral machines. And inside the ring, their chemistry clicked.
But cracks soon began to form.
The Fallout: Ego, Infighting, and a Reign in Decline
As their reign stretched into the summer of 2024, the honeymoon ended.
Waller’s impulsiveness got them into matches they weren’t ready for. Theory’s need for validation had him chasing singles attention. They dropped the titles at SummerSlam in controversial fashion to DIY, prompting a backstage shouting match that didn’t go unnoticed.
What followed was months of dysfunction.
Segments saw them cut each other off mid-promo. Matches ended in miscommunication. Waller cost Theory a shot at the Intercontinental Title. Theory mocked Waller’s constant need to host talk shows rather than win matches. In backstage vignettes, you could see it – the eye rolls, the silent walk-offs, the barely contained contempt.
Still, week after week, they insisted they were fine.
But over the past two weeks on Monday Night RAW, things have taken another sharp turn.
The Waller Switch-Up: New Day, New Vibe
In a move few saw coming, Grayson Waller has been seen backstage and at ringside rolling with The New Day – specifically the now-heel duo of Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods, who turned on Big E last year in a shocking in-ring promo segment that shook fans and solidified their dark evolution.
The New Day aren’t throwing pancakes anymore – they’re throwing fists and firing shots.
As of now, they are the reigning WWE World Tag Team Champions, having won the gold in dramatic fashion at WrestleMania 41 Night 1. And next week on Raw, they defend those titles against The Judgment Day’s Finn Bálor and JD McDonagh – another dangerous, chaotic unit.
Where does Waller fit into this?
That’s the question.
Whether he’s manipulating his way into a new trio, replacing Big E in the group, or just playing mind games with Theory – it’s clear Grayson Waller isn’t waiting around. He’s moving on. And he’s moving fast.
Can They Reunite – or Are We Heading for a Collision?
There are two possibilities moving forward – and both could shake WWE’s future.
1. Reconciliation: Rebranding the Brand
If A-Town Down Under can channel their earlier spark, they could launch into a dominant second act. A babyface turn for the duo – if handled right – could tap into the audience’s genuine appreciation for their humor, chemistry, and underdog appeal.
But it would take humility, and both men shedding their stubbornness.
That feels unlikely.
2. The Breakup: The Generational Feud
The more likely scenario is war. And it could be electric.
Imagine it: A mid-match miscue leads to a beatdown. One man snaps. Waller low-blows Theory. Or Theory finally decks Waller. The breakup would be emotional and bitter – not a clean split, but a slow-burning unraveling with weeks of sabotage.
And the feud?
Austin Theory, cast aside and finally sick of being laughed at, embraces the crowd. He’s fought legends, bled on the big stage, and sacrificed potential for others’ egos. A fiery babyface run could ignite his career like never before – think Seth Rollins 2019 or even John Cena 2005.
Grayson Waller, meanwhile, could stay true to himself – a manipulative, camera-loving egomaniac who spins the narrative his way. But there’s also a path where he turns face – frustrated that Theory abandoned him, painted as the villain, even though he tried to hold them together. That road would be more nuanced… and more emotional.
The matches would be show-stealing. The promos? Scathing. The story? Personal.
One More Round: Could the Band Get Back Together?
In wrestling, the breakup is often just one act in a longer play. Like The Shield, DIY, or even Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn – some bonds are too strong to stay broken forever.
Years from now, a wiser Theory and Waller could reunite. Maybe to fight a new generation of loudmouths. Maybe for one last run at the titles they made famous. Maybe in mutual respect – or mutual hatred of someone else.
The story isn’t over. It’s just entering its next chapter.
Conclusion: A Legacy Written in Ego and Electricity
A-Town Down Under was lightning in a bottle – two egos who found magic together. Their rise was meteoric, their reign iconic, and their downfall inevitable.
Now comes the question every great team must face: can they evolve together, or will they thrive apart?
No matter the path, one thing is clear – Theory and Waller aren’t just WWE’s future.
They are WWE’s now.
And the world is watching what comes next.
Make sure to subscribe to our Late Night Crew Wrestling YouTube Channel. Follow @yorkjavon, @kspowerwheels & @LateNightCrewYT on X.
