WWE spent weeks building intrigue around Randy Orton’s mystery caller, only for the reveal of Pat McAfee to drag Cody Rhodes’ title feud into a sideshow that never fully clicked. The backlash was immediate, the complaints kept growing, and the focus drifted further away from the actual story. That is what made Cody Rhodes destroying The Pat McAfee Show set and taking back his championship feel less like a stunt and more like a needed correction.
For the first time in weeks, this feud felt like it remembered who it was really about.
A big reason fans turned on this so fast comes down to the way WWE framed the mystery. The company did not present it like a throwaway reveal. It was treated like Orton had somebody important in his ear, somebody who could shift the balance of the feud and add another real layer to his issue with Cody. That naturally made people expect a payoff with more weight behind it. So when SmackDown revealed McAfee as the caller, had him align with Orton, and then watched the angle immediately swing in his direction, it landed with more frustration than excitement. The issue was never whether McAfee could get a reaction. The issue was that the reveal felt smaller than the build, and from that point on the story started slipping away from Cody and Orton.
That frustration only got louder once the reports and rumors about outside influence started making the rounds. Whether people bought all of it or not, the perception was already there. Fans were not watching this like a clean wrestling story anymore. They were watching it like a feud that had been pushed off course by buzz, crossover appeal, and the need to force McAfee into a bigger spot than the story called for. Once that feeling set in, every segment got picked apart even harder, because instead of coming off like a natural escalation between Cody and Orton, the whole thing started feeling manufactured.
Then came the follow-up, and that only made matters worse. McAfee kept talking, kept inserting himself deeper into the feud, and kept taking up more space in a story that should have stayed centered on Cody and Orton. By the time he was standing tall with the title, a lot of fans were beyond annoyed. Cody looked like he was getting lost in his own feud, Orton at times felt like he was sharing a spotlight that should have been his, and McAfee had somehow become the loudest voice in one of WWE’s biggest WrestleMania programs. That is why Cody’s response worked. It cut through all the extra noise at once.
Cody destroying McAfee’s set and taking back the title was the first thing in this story that felt clean, direct, and actually satisfying. It was not just about payback. It was about finally giving the feud a moment that pushed the right person back to the front. Instead of another talking segment, another cheap shot, or another attempt to turn fan backlash into part of the gimmick, Cody gave the story something physical and decisive. He hit back, he got his title, and he reminded everyone that this feud works a lot better when it is built around the champion refusing to be played with.
That does not erase the criticism surrounding the mystery caller reveal or the weeks of damage that came after it. Fans are still split on McAfee’s involvement, and there is a real argument that WWE overthought something that never needed this much extra dressing in the first place. But Cody’s retaliation did what the reveal could not. It gave the story direction, gave Cody some bite back, and finally made the feud feel like it had a pulse again. After weeks of this thing drifting into the wrong hands, Cody smashing up The Pat McAfee Show set and walking away with his championship was the first real sign that the story had found its way back.
Make sure to subscribe to our Late Night Crew Wrestling YouTube Channel. Follow @yorkjavon, @kspowerwheels & @LateNightCrewYT on X.
I’m the quiet one until the bell rings then I’ve got takes. I live for WWE NXT and TNA, I want every promotion to succeed, and I will absolutely roast the bad decisions on sight (because someone has to). Anime taught me to respect long-term storytelling; wrestling taught me that sometimes the plan is “we panicked” and called it “unpredictable.” The Miz got me into all of this, so yeah I appreciate confidence, commitment, and the art of talking like you’re already the main event. Now I bring that same energy to the page as the main writer for Late Night Crew Wrestling because if you’re not here to be must-see and tell the truth, why are you here?!