WWE had three hours, the WrestleMania stage, a loaded roster, and one final chance to make the blue brand feel essential heading into the biggest weekend of the year. Instead, last night’s WWE Friday Night SmackDown felt like a show that kept teasing urgency without ever fully committing to it. Randy Orton finally delivered the kind of personal, pointed promo that gave his WrestleMania match with Cody Rhodes some real meat on the bone, but that clarity came far too late in the build. Royce Keys got the career-changing moment of winning the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, Tiffany Stratton moved one step closer to more singles gold, and the WWE Tag Team Titles were defended in a match that only raised more questions about the company’s tag team priorities on the eve of WrestleMania. By the end of the night, the biggest issue was not that SmackDown was bad from top to bottom. It was that too much of it felt padded, strangely structured, and disconnected from the level of excitement this weekend should have right now.
Here are the full results
- The MFTs def. The Wyatt Sicks (Eight-Man Tag Team Street Fight)
- Damian Priest & R-Truth (c) def. Kofi Kingston & Grayson Waller (WWE Tag Team Championship)
- Tiffany Stratton def. Jordynne Grace (No. 1 Contender’s Match for the Women’s United States Championship)
- Royce Keys won the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal
- Charlotte Flair & Alexa Bliss vs. Bayley & Lyra Valkyria never officially got underway after a pre-match brawl involving the Irresistible Forces escalated the WrestleMania women’s tag title situation
Breakdowns & Reactions
Randy Orton opened the show and, at long last, gave this Cody Rhodes feud the kind of personal framing it has been missing. That was the strongest thing on the entire episode. Orton finally spoke with the kind of bitterness and history this rivalry always needed, painting Cody as someone who takes from the people around him and tying that resentment back to their shared past. It gave the WrestleMania match real emotional footing, and that only made it more frustrating that WWE waited until the final SmackDown before Mania to get there. The core story was sitting right there the whole time, and the show practically admitted it by how much stronger the feud felt once Orton stopped circling around it and actually said something with substance. That part of your reaction lines up closely with the broader response. A lot of the coverage coming out of the show treated Orton’s promo as the one segment that actually sharpened the Cody match in a meaningful way.
At the same time, the Pat McAfee problem still hung over everything. Even when SmackDown finally stumbled into the right story for Cody and Orton, Pat still felt forced into the middle of it. That has been one of the major complaints around this feud, and last night did not do much to fix it. The opening stretch dragged because it kept orbiting McAfee, directly or indirectly, before the show ever got to its first real match. That is a big reason why the first twenty minutes felt so frustrating. The show did not open with immediate WrestleMania urgency. It opened by lingering on a celebrity-adjacent attachment that still has not felt natural to the feud. Fans and outside coverage were not in lockstep on every detail, but there was a clear shared feeling that McAfee’s presence has complicated a story that works better when it stays centered on Cody and Orton.
That slow start fed into the larger issue of the night: if WWE wanted a three-hour SmackDown, this was not the way to justify it. This did not feel like a show maximizing extra time. It felt like a show filling it. That is not the same thing. The pacing early on was loose, the structure did not feel urgent, and several segments came off like placeholders rather than final, hard-selling WrestleMania hooks. The complaint that WWE asked for three hours only to do the bare minimum is harsh, but last night gave it plenty of fuel. This should have felt like a loaded final sprint. Too often, it felt like a show coasting on the fact that WrestleMania is already here.
The eight-man street fight was a good example of that problem. On paper, a chaotic gimmick match should have injected some life into the show. In practice, the bout felt like it was trying to manufacture excitement rather than naturally creating it. The crowd reaction never came off as especially strong, and the whole thing had the familiar feeling of commentary pushing hard to frame the match as bigger and more important than it actually felt in the building. Add in the stop-and-start rhythm that comes with commercial breaks cutting through the action, and it became more exhausting than gripping. The match was not a disaster, but it absolutely did not land like a major WrestleMania-week centerpiece. That matched a lot of the fan criticism and lined up with the colder outside reaction to this feud as a whole.
Royce Keys winning the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal was the biggest result of the night on paper, but it also created one of the most obvious questions coming out of the show: now what? WWE clearly wanted a surprise winner and a fresh talking point, and in that sense the match did its job. Joe Hendry’s inclusion also felt like a deliberate attempt to juice interest in a battle royal that fans usually do not treat as especially meaningful anymore. That part worked in the moment. Hendry gave the match extra buzz, and Keys walking out with the trophy was a genuine surprise. The problem is that a surprise is not the same thing as momentum. If Keys is going to be taken seriously after this, WWE has to follow through fast. Otherwise, this will just be another Andre win that produces a reaction on the night and then fades almost immediately. That concern was all over the post-show discussion and the outside coverage too.
The WWE Tag Team Title defense was another booking choice that felt backwards. Damian Priest and R-Truth retained, but the bigger issue was why this match existed in this spot at all. On the night before WrestleMania weekend, WWE chose to have the SmackDown tag champions defend against a team that was not even a natural blue-brand focal point, and the result did little to strengthen the division or elevate the title scene. That is the frustration. Instead of giving the champions a meaningful SmackDown-based story and challengers that actually feel connected to the brand, WWE burned a title defense in a way that felt more like content management than real direction. It was not a bad match. It just felt like the wrong priority at the wrong time.
Tiffany Stratton beating Jordynne Grace was another result that is going to spark debate because the match itself only added to the feeling that Grace’s momentum has cooled off in a hurry. Grace arrived with a strong aura and obvious upside, but the main-roster handling has not consistently protected that feeling. Last night did not help. Tiffany winning makes sense if WWE wants a bigger singles title spotlight for her, but Grace taking another notable loss feeds the perception that the company has already chipped away at the presentation that made her feel special in the first place. That is not just one frustrated fan reading too much into a single result. That concern has been building, and last night kept it alive.
The women’s tag title scene also continued to feel like a missed opportunity. WWE has more than enough star power in that WrestleMania fatal four-way to make the match feel important, but the build has not matched the talent involved. Last night was more proof of that. Instead of using the final SmackDown to sharpen the rivalries and pay off the stories already sitting there, the show went with another chaotic brawl setup that made the match feel even more like a collection of names than a story fans are deeply invested in. That has been one of the loudest complaints around this year’s WrestleMania build in general. The pieces are there, but the company has too often settled for surface-level heat instead of meaningful progression.
Another recurring WWE habit that stood out again was putting wrestlers ringside without truly using them. If they are not going to be on commentary, add texture, or directly deepen the angle, it keeps feeling like an empty visual shortcut rather than storytelling. That issue is part of a bigger pattern with this show. Too much of SmackDown felt like WWE reminding fans that stories exist instead of actually advancing them in a memorable way. On the final show before WrestleMania, that is not enough.
Then there was the closing Cody Rhodes and CM Punk segment, which was one of the most divisive parts of the night. Coming out of the show, a lot of the reaction landed in the same place you did: it felt unnecessary. Not because Cody and Punk cannot share the ring or create interest, but because it was an odd emotional note to end on when WrestleMania needed sharper conflict, clearer hype, and stronger focus on the feuds that are actually supposed to drive the weekend. SmackDown had already spent much of the night trying to repair focus around Cody and Orton. Closing with Cody and Punk standing tall together only made the final image feel more muddled. That was one of the clearest examples of the show losing sight of what it most needed to accomplish.
That is what defined this episode in the end. SmackDown was not empty. Things happened. Orton delivered. Keys got a major moment. Tiffany moved forward. The tag champions retained. WrestleMania stories were technically advanced. But almost nothing about the overall show screamed that fans should be over the moon heading into WrestleMania. For a go-home episode with three hours to work with, that is the real failure. The strongest parts of the show were the parts where WWE finally got direct and personal. Too much of the rest felt padded, overthought, or weirdly detached from the urgency the weekend needed. That is why the reaction coming out of the show has been so mixed. There were talking points, but not enough real momentum.
Make sure to subscribe to our Late Night Crew Wrestling YouTube Channel. Follow @yorkjavon, @kspowerwheels & @LateNightCrewYT on X.
I’m the quiet one until the bell rings then I’ve got takes. I live for WWE NXT and TNA, I want every promotion to succeed, and I will absolutely roast the bad decisions on sight (because someone has to). Anime taught me to respect long-term storytelling; wrestling taught me that sometimes the plan is “we panicked” and called it “unpredictable.” The Miz got me into all of this, so yeah I appreciate confidence, commitment, and the art of talking like you’re already the main event. Now I bring that same energy to the page as the main writer for Late Night Crew Wrestling because if you’re not here to be must-see and tell the truth, why are you here?!